Few lease disputes reach the financial press, but the one that has grabbed the attention of the Financial Times is between The Crown Estate and Veeraswamy, the UK's oldest Indian restaurant, which opened in 1926 on Regent Street.
Heritage and royalty aside, the case highlights something every landlord and tenant needs to consider: the security of tenure regime in the Landlord and Tenant Act. The court case is equally relevant in Gibraltar where a comparable statutory security of tenure regime applies to business tenancies.
The Landlord and Tenant Act seeks to balance the legitimate landlord redevelopment ambitions against the security of tenure of established business tenants.
The restaurant's lease at Victory House expired in June 2025. The Crown Estate told the tenant that it would oppose any court application for a lease renewal on the basis that it wants to carry out a “comprehensive refurbishment” of the upper floor vacant offices to convert them into premium office spaces which could not be carried out without obtaining possession. Its 12 month renovation plans, for which it has obtained planning permission and listed building consent, include expanding the building's reception area which, it argues, would allow it to charge future office tenants higher rents.
The Crown Estate offered the statutory compensation in the amount of £500,000 and relocation to alternative premises. The restaurant's owner argued that this falls short of the actual commercial consequences of relocation including loss of goodwill and customer loyalty as well as the actual cost of fitting out alternative premises which it estimates to be £5million.
The key issue for the Court to consider will be whether the landlord genuinely needs to recover possession of the restaurant's premises to carry out its refurbishment of Victory House. The trial has concluded and judgment is awaited.
A recent decision in the Supreme Court of Gibraltar shows how the court recently balanced a landlord's firm and genuine redevelopment plans against a tenant's statutory right to a renewal lease and ruled in favour of the landlord who sought to insert a landlord's redevelopment break clause in the renewal lease within the five-year minimum term.
These cases highlight the importance for both landlords and tenants to treat future plans for the building as a key commercial term to negotiate early, not something to consider at lease expiry.
Early advice and careful drafting remain the best way to protect both sides, and whatever the judgment in Veeraswamy, that lesson applies as much on Main Street as on Regent Street.
For more insights from our legal experts, please subscribe here.
The Landlord and Tenant Act seeks to balance the legitimate landlord redevelopment ambitions against the security of tenure of established business tenants.
www.ft.com/...

