Mental Capacity and Wills: The importance of detailed assessments and notes

Firstly, instructions should be received directly from the testator and family members and potential beneficiaries should be requested to leave the room in any relevant meetings.

Secondly, legal practitioners should ensure that a testator has the mental capacity to make a Will. It is good practice to following the test set out in Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549 and record in writing any relevant information gathered in detail.

Finally, they should follow the “Golden Rule”, an expected professional standard which entails a medical practitioner conducting an appropriate examination of the testator at the time of execution of the Will and the conclusions of such examination recorded in writing. The “Golden Rule” also advises that a medical practitioner act as a second witness to the Will. 

All file notes, assessments and opinions should be kept with the original Will. These documents could prove to be important as the burden of proof, when capacity is questioned, lies with the persons trying to prove the Will and not those contesting it.

It should be noted that following the Banks v Goodfellow test and the “Golden Rule” does not necessarily guarantee that the testator had capacity. It does however, make it very difficult to show otherwise. 

Press Releases

Hassans’ Grahame Jackson awarded an Advanced Diploma in International Taxation

Grahame Jackson, Tax Partner at Hassans, was recently awarded an Advanced Diploma in International Taxation

Hassans International Law Firm becomes a Limited Company

Hassans has announced that as of today, Wednesday 1st July, it will be operating as

Hassans donates £35,000 in support of GHA workers

In support of the continuing demands being faced by the GHA, Hassans has made a

Hassans advises Tap Global on gaining full DLT licence approval

Hassans’ client, Tap Global (TAP), has today received full DLT licence approval from the Gibraltar

“Super Thursday” – three new tax related provisions introduced by Gibraltar.

On Super Thursday, the 30th January 2020, HM Government of Gibraltar (HM GoG) published a

EU Prudential Supervision of Investment Firms

The European Parliament has approved legislation which will see new rules in relation to the

View more

Activity Stream

Congratulations to @JamesNoguera for completing the Calendar Club Challenge. He was joined by Tim Garcia & @MatthewTorres87 for the last leg on Tuesday. James and his fellow fundraisers ran 462km in June and have raised over £27,000 so far. A great achievement, well done boys!

Last week

Spanish Supreme Court rules that the ban on online gaming prior to law 13/2011 was contrary to EU Law by @AMontegriffo

Last week

Originally planned to take place in Buenos Aires, @ianfelice and @JemmaEmmerson are attending a 2 half-day online #FIFA Football Law Annual Review, full agenda here #regulatory #disciplinary #compliance

About 2 weeks ago

Project Restart? Hassans' Jemma Emmerson looks at why women's football won't be coming home anytime soon. #sports

About 2 weeks ago

Great piece on promoting social justice through sport by Hassans’ Partner @ianfelice #sports #TakingAKnee #SocialJustice

About 3 weeks ago